Search Public Service Bookstore & License
YouTube
Linkedin
繁 简 EN
A A A

Marking and Processing of Marks

The HKEAA has a set of comprehensive procedures for marking and processing of marks to ensure fairness and consistency.

  1. 01

    Appointment of markers

    Applicants' academic qualifications, and teaching and marking experience are the key elements for consideration in the selection process. All markers are required to undertake rigorous training and to be qualified for marking. Each year, around 4 000 markers are recruited, most of whom are teachers.
  2. 02

    Marking scheme

    Prepared by the moderation committee, the marking scheme serves as a guide to markers on how marks should be awarded, taking into consideration the question requirements and the range of acceptable responses. Moderation committees, each comprising a Chief Examiner, a setter or co-setters, moderators and an HKEAA subject manager, are responsible for the development of question papers and marking schemes.

    Marking schemes are not model answers. Answers not covered by the marking scheme could also score marks if they are relevant to the question and logically presented.

  3. 03

    Sample scripts selection

    After the examination, sample scripts covering different approaches of candidates’ responses and illustrating performance in relation to the level descriptors are selected. These samples provide useful material for standardising marking and for grading.
  4. 04

    Standardisation meeting

    The examiners compare marks awarded to the sample scripts, agree on marking principles and standards, and revise the marking scheme, where necessary, before the markers’ meeting.
  5. 05

    Markers' meeting

    The examiners brief markers on the assessment objectives and demands of individual questions. Some sample scripts are trial marked by markers to identify and rectify discrepancies in the interpretation of the marking scheme.
  6. 06

    Allocation of scripts to markers

    Candidates are assigned random candidate numbers by computer. Since the 2015 HKDSE, the written papers of all subjects have adopted onscreen marking (OSM) in which candidates’ scripts are randomly distributed to markers, with scripts from their students or close family members excluded in the distribution.Markers do not know the identity of the candidates.
  7. 07

    Marking

    Markers must demonstrate that they have mastered the marking standards before they can proceed to mark the scripts. For scripts that are double-marked, there will be two raw marks awarded independently by two different markers. If there is a big discrepancy between these two marks, a third marker will mark the script. A fourth marking will also be conducted if there is a continuing discrepancy, to ensure a fair assessment of the script. Normally, the closest, highest pair of marks is added up to form the raw mark for the script.
  8. 08

    Checkmarking

    The marked scripts of each marker undergo at least two stages of checkmarking by the examiners to ensure consistency and to spot problems of marking. If a script has been selected for checkmarking, the mark awarded by the checkmarker is also recorded and may override the raw mark if deemed more reliable.
  9. 09

    Addition of marks

    As scripts are marked onscreen, marks are automatically added up and checked by the computer system.
 

 

Points to Note

It should be noted that marking involves professional judgements and is not an exact science. Different markers may not award identical marks to the same answer, particularly for questions of an open-ended nature.Marks awarded by persons who have not been trained or standardised cannot be regarded as valid assessments of candidates’ performance.

After marking is completed, various processes are adopted to ensure that the marks awarded by markers, the marks in different optional parts and the marks of different papers are fair and comparable before they are aggregated to form the subject mark.

From raw mark to subject mark

After the completion of marking, the mark statistics of each marker’s batch of scripts are checked. Coupled with evidence gathered from checkmarking, appropriate actions such as mark adjustment or remarking are taken to rectify marking that is too lenient, strict or erratic. These processes give rise to the adjusted mark.

In some subjects where there are optional sections or papers, the adjusted marks of the optional parts may be equated so that the performance of candidates choosing different options can be reflected on the same scale. This process gives rise to the equated mark. One example is found in English Language Paper 1 (Reading) and Paper 3 (Listening & Integrated Skills) where all candidates must do Part A and choose either Part B1 (easier section) or Part B2 (more difficult section). To assess the performance of candidates choosing different sections on the same scale, each mark in the scale of the easier section will be converted to an equivalent mark in the more difficult section.

After mark adjustment and, if applicable, mark equating, the adjusted / equated marks of each question / section achieved by a candidate in an examination paper are then added up according to their relative weightings to form the paper mark.

If a subject consists of two or more examination papers, the adjusted marks (or equated marks if applicable) of individual examination papers are converted to the same scale, taking into account the spread of marks in different papers and the published paper weightings, to form the weighted paper marks. This is done because the overall performance of candidates, in terms of the mean and spread of adjusted marks, may be different across the examination papers for a subject and so these marks are not directly comparable with each other (Please click here for details of the relevant example). The weighted paper marks for each examination paper represent the final marks for each candidate, and are added together forming the subject mark for subjects with no School-based Assessment (SBA).

 

Subjects with School-based Assessment (SBA)

For subjects with SBA, the SBA marks submitted by schools are moderated to iron out possible differences in marking standards among teachers, and the mean and spread of marks of a school are adjusted (click here for details). Because of this, the SBA marks can be directly combined with the weighted examination paper marks for a subject, with no further conversion, in accordance with the prescribed weightings to achieve the subject mark for each candidate.

For subjects with both component and subject results reported, the subject mark is the sum of all the component marks. For components comprising one examination paper and the SBA, the weighted paper marks of the constituent paper and the moderated SBA marks are added up to form the component mark according to their weighting as stipulated in the Assessment Framework. If the component consists of only one paper, the component mark is the same as the weighted paper mark.

SBA results are not separately reported in the Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education. However, profile reporting is adopted for Chinese Language and English Language. The SBA results of these subjects will be reported together with the relevant examination paper in the component concerned.

Below is a summary of the various processes adopted in the processing of marks described above:

Process
Mark generated
Remarks
Marking Raw mark Marks given by marker(s).
Mark adjustment Adjusted mark Marks awarded by markers are adjusted, if necessary, to rectify lenient, strict or erratic marking.
Mark equating (if applicable) Equated mark Marks of one optional part are equated to those of another optional part (e.g. in English Language Paper 1 (Reading) and Paper 3 (Listening & Integrated Skills), marks of the easier section are converted to equivalent marks in the more difficult section).
Forming paper mark Paper mark After adjustment / equating, marks of all questions / sections within a paper are added up according to the weighting of the questions / sections in the paper.
Forming weighted paper mark Weighted paper mark Marks of different papers are converted to the same comparable scale, taking into account the spread of marks in different papers and the published paper weightings, before they are combined to form the subject mark.
Forming component mark* Component mark For components with only one paper, the component mark is the same as the weighted paper mark. For components consisting of one examination paper and the SBA^, the component mark is the sum of the weighted paper mark and the moderated SBA mark according to their weighting as stipulated in the Assessment Framework.
Forming subject mark Subject mark The subject mark is the sum of the weighted paper marks and the moderated SBA marks (if applicable). During the grading process, the subject level is determined based on the subject mark. Please click here for details regarding the grading process.

For Chinese Language and English Language, the subject mark is the sum of the marks of all the components. The subject level of these subjects is not the average of the component levels but is based on the candidate’s subject mark.

* Applicable only to Chinese Language and English Language, where component results are reported in addition to the subject result.

^ Component 1 (Reading and Integrated Skills) of Chinese Language comprises the results of Paper 1 and the SBA, while Component 4 (Speaking) of English Language comprises the results of Paper 4 and the SBA.

In view of recent technological developments, the HKEAA has adopted a series of innovative and advanced technologies to enhance operation of examinations. First introduced in 2007, Onscreen Marking (OSM) was adopted to improve the security, quality, reliability and efficiency of marking. The vast majority of answer scripts of the HKDSE are marked onscreen. It has also been adopted to the Language Proficiency Assessment for Teachers (LPAT) and the Territory-wide System Assessment (TSA).